Rainbowfish Documentation Project (was Re: The Science/Hobby

Andrew Boyd (andrew at pcug.org.au)
Fri, 31 May 1996 11:11:18 +1000

At 09:58 AM 5/28/96 -0800, Scott Buckel wrote:
> Reply to: RE>>The Science/Hobby Interface (was RE: Water)
>
>As a working scientist I and others have found that the initial design of
>experiments is often times the most difficult part of scientific study.
>Frequently, scientists design experiments that are not rigorous initially to
>see what may or may not be important and relevant, then go on to the very
>rigorous experiment that can lead to verifiable conclusions.

Or sometimes come to a conclusion and design an experiment to verify it ;).

>I could see that fisheries biologists that are attempting to produce
>commercial quantaties of fish could benefit from the "primative" experiment
>done by aquarists. I have done some experiments in the past (I should have
>them up) and I know that individuals like Roy Hunter (RSG) have done simple
>experiments to find optimal cultural conditions in fishroom. Aquarists could
>help and contrubute if we would do a few things like parallel culture
>experiments and then write them up (I know that would please a few editors I
>know!).

These aquarists' experiments may or may not aid the scientific community -
but they will aid all aquarists in the long run if they are properly
documented. This would certainly please a few editors around the place!
It's hard to know the best place to publish this information, though.
Fishes of Sahul does get around to quite a few countries, but I'm not sure
if Ron would go for this sort of thing. Maybe the various ANGFA/RSG and
members' web pages, with appropriate pointers in the rest? Could we start
the "RDP" (Rainbowfish Documentation Project)? It would be a big effort, I
guess. Collation of anecdotal information on all the species would be a
good start, with experiments to verify - the calcium discussion was
interesting, with some fishes being hatched in water of Red Sea hardness,
others being hatched in almost distilled water by comparison, and the
TB/Ulcer discussion was good value too - maybe we all we really need to do
via this list is to appoint an official summariser! Comments?

Regards, Andrew Boyd
___________________________________________________________________
Andrew Boyd - andrew at pcug.org.au - http://www.pcug.org.au/~andrew
"A cyberpunk is a technonerd who gets laid"
___________________________________________________________________