Re: [RML] Naming Fish

peter.unmack at ASU.Edu
Tue, 20 Jan 1998 07:28:16 -0700 (MST)

On Tue, 20 Jan 1998, Doug Collom wrote:

First off, would you mind going into Microsoft Outlook Express and
switching off all the html stuff and just make the messages plain text. I
usually delete messages full of that without reading them as it is
difficult to read with all the codes spread throughout. :-)

> The only problem here could be corruption into the " South Australian " =
> rainbow. They certainly occur in SA ( I keep a few of them ) but there =
> are more of them a long way north of the Murray. Southern also allows =
> later discrimination into " Murray " and " Condamine " types if we need =
> to. They are much brighter up our way, and tend to be a bit different in =
> shape and size.=20

You Qlders all think your fish are best. I've kept 'em from all over and
there is little difference in brightness between SA, Vic, or Qld. :-)
Murray-Darling rainbow is just as much as a mouthful as east coast
rainbow. Why not just say Murray rainbow? And incidentally, there are
probably just as many, if not more in SA and some spots in Vic than the
Condamine. :-) We once managed ~170 from 30 meters of sampling with a 7
meter seine in the Broken River near Benalla. That article many years ago
by Romanowski on how rare rainbows were in Vic was largely speculative and
inaccurate based upon information that he didn't know about when he wrote
it.

> So what's the reaction to these nominations. ( I'm on a roll - Get in =
> quick before I create more ! )=20

I think you are wasting your time. Aside from the fact that coming up
with a whole new set of names won't help things. Someone suggested going
through Allen's book and working from there. Inventing new names will
only increase confusion. Stick to calling them by species followed by
their river and township name. No need to fix something that ain't broke.
Who in rainbowfish circles really uses many common names anyway? Sure,
many shops do but how often do they have the right fish to begin with? Why
not spend your time writing on some of the fishes you keep for Fishes of
Sahul or the Bulletin. No one has ever written on care and keeping of
fluvies, it would be a good contribution.

Tootles :-)

Peter Unmack