Re: [RML] Naming Fish

Bruce Hansen (bhansen at ozemail.com.au)
Wed, 21 Jan 1998 06:04:54 +1000

I'm not sure that Doug isn't proposing more problems than he is solving -
as is often the case with Doug when you get to know him ;-)

I think we should try to echo the scientific name as much as possible too
as a general principle as well as take into account already publicised
names and Gerry Allen has already called MSS the "Eastern" Rainbowfish. I
guess I don't have a problem with considering "splendid" for it even if
there are some forms that aren't too splendid.AQnd whether we like his
common names or not they are already imprinted worldwide on Rainbowfish
enthusiasts.

"Inornata" is supposed to mean 'not ornate' but many forms are - so I guess
we should stay with "Checquered" especially since we still have
Rhadinocentrus with the already bestowed "ornatus" tag ;-) Besides I still
like "Sunfish" for them.And "Capricorn" does nothing for me either ;-(

On reflection perhaps I have done my own little bit of confsuing ;-)

Regards,
Bruce.

Bruce Hansen, ANGFA, caring for our aquatic ecosystems.

Please visit us at http://www.ozemail.com.au/~fisher/angfa.htm

----------
From: Doug Collom <dcollom at powerup.com.au>
To: rainbowfish mailing list <rainbowfish at pcug.org.au>
Subject: [RML] Naming Fish
Date: Tuesday, 20 January 1998 22:29

It's good it see that quite a few of you have thought about this common
name thing in the past. I agree with just about all you said Matthew,
particularly about locality names. There is a bit of a problem however with
some of the species from wider distributions. I'll illustrate that with
some of my thoughts about the local fish here that I mentioned, the
duboulayi, fluviatilis and splendida.

I favour calling the duboulayi by its locality, the " East Coast " rainbow.
Its range is coastal only, and smack dab in the middle of Australia's East
coast. I'll return to this in a few lines.

The fluvies are to me " Southern Rainbows ". There is no disputing they are
the most southerly lot, and " Murray-Darling " rainbow is a bit of a
mouthful.

The only problem here could be corruption into the " South Australian "
rainbow. They certainly occur in SA ( I keep a few of them ) but there are
more of them a long way north of the Murray. Southern also allows later
discrimination into " Murray " and " Condamine " types if we need to. They
are much brighter up our way, and tend to be a bit different in shape and
size.

Which brings me to the problem one, splendida splendida. I don't favour
splendid rainbow, there are some very colourful variations, but some other
species out-splendid them.

With North- East rainbow we strike the problem north-east what ? New Guinea
has a long NE coast too. In fact splendida are not actually north east fish
at all, that's more up Cape York, and " Southern end of the North East of
Australia " lacks appeal. ( And that promised brief return to my " East
Coast " tag, New Guinea fortunately doesn't feature much directly East
Coast, so I might get away with that one. )

In fact splendida are not purely coastal either. There are more splendida
inland, a long way from the coast, in the two huge catchments of the
Fitzroy and the Burdekin rivers, than along the coast.

The Fitzroy enters the sea right on the Tropic of Capricorn, and the
catchment extends way south to behind the Burnett, and North to behind
Mackay. The Burdekin catchment also has a huge North -South spread, and
actually reaches below the Tropic, west of the Fitzroy catchment.

Are you getting ahead of me ?

With this range of distribution I think " Capricorn " rainbow might be a
good tag. Sorry Matthew, I've had to invent that one, but geographically
its logical, and an attractive name. I know they go up to Cooktown way, but
" Capricorn Rainbow " is the most serviceable and accurate I've come up
with yet. Like the fluvies too it will allow discriminating Burdekins,
Wallabys etc.

So what's the reaction to these nominations. ( I'm on a roll - Get in quick
before I create more ! )

Doug Collom