RE: Re: [RML] herbies/tris/rainbow evolution

Andrew Boyd (andrew at pcug.org.au)
Sat, 21 Dec 1996 23:36:45 +1100

At 03:24 PM 12/20/96 +0100, Harro wrote:
>>Correct me if I am wrong but edith and waterfall cr are a fair distance
>>away. I dont think its a fish below and a fish above example. I dont think
>>there would be any difference in the two in that example. Fish from above
>>would fall to the fish below keeping the two populations "together".
>>Edith cr exqusita's were the fish described as exqusita. I dont believe the
>>fish from waterfall were ever looked at in the same capacity.
>
>>Roy Hunter
>
>I have seen both exquisitas and at present I tend to the idea that it really
>may be two different species. Wim should write a little bit more about them?
>Please, Wim, report also about the breeding!

I may be totally out of line here, but I think that there comes a point
where we have to leave the taxonomy/speciation stuff to the scientists - all
we can really do as hobbyists (well, speaking from my POV as a hobbyist) is
maintain the different populations seperately - we tend to place a high
loading on a species that only occurs in the one place, such as M. pygmaea,
(well, aside from the fact that they are nice little fish that are buggers
to breed) and maybe less on one type/locality of M.trifasciata.... Remember
the M.eachamensis, that we are now told isn't as endangered as a species as
we once thought?

I think that *as long as* the fish is correctly identified in the first
place, the subsequent name changes/DNA findings can be agonised over after
they've become official. If we keep them alive, then we can sort the name
out later.

Regards, Andrew

><> <>< ><> Andrew Boyd - andrew at pcug.org.au - Frex at FurryMUCK!
<>< <>< : http://www.pcug.org.au/~andrew
><> <>< IRC #rainbowfish: http://www.pcug.org.au/~andrew/rainbow.htm
<>< : ><> Rainbowfish Mailing List: http://www.pcug.org.au/~andrew/rml.htm
: <>< Sthn. Hemisphere Killifish List: http://www.killi.net/aunzza/
Happiness is merely the remission of pain... (from A Gentleman)