As a working scientist I and others have found that the initial design of
experiments is often times the most difficult part of scientific study.
Frequently, scientists design experiments that are not rigorous initially to
see what may or may not be important and relevant, then go on to the very
rigorous experiment that can lead to verifiable conclusions.
I could see that aquarists could help the scientists, if the scientists would
listen to aquarists. These qualitative observations could lead them to the
important experiments. (I will admit this is difficult for a scientist to do
as I have to interact with many different areas in my work, and when I hear
comments from other areas I frequently will discount it and not really listen
to the comments. A few years ago I started trying to listening a little
better and the comments were not very good, but it made me think allong
different lines to do the important experiment).
I could see that fisheries biologists that are attempting to produce
commercial quantaties of fish could benefit from the "primative" experiment
done by aquarists. I have done some experiments in the past (I should have
them up) and I know that individuals like Roy Hunter (RSG) have done simple
experiments to find optimal cultural conditions in fishroom. Aquarists could
help and contrubute if we would do a few things like parallel culture
experiments and then write them up (I know that would please a few editors I
know!).
Scott Buckel (RSG)
--------------------------------------
Date: 5/27/96 3:59 PM
To: Scott Buckel
From: rainbowfish at pcug.org.au
I guess Peter's :-) comment <<That's why there will always be a big gap
between scientists and
>aquarists and why scientists will never pay much attention to most
>aquarists. :-)>>
really gets to the marrow of one of the reasons for this list. I for one hope
it will provide an interface between the two aspects - science and hobby.
I practice a profession which deals with the applications of the research
that the scientists painstakingly perform. However most of their projects are
designed to investigate a theory or prove a hypothesis or explain aan
observation or some other such reason. For other scientists to believe their
results the evedence needs to be assembled in an approved format and the
methodology similarly designed to exclude factors that may introduce bias.The
necessary painstaking recording of the evidence and analysis of the results
is vital to the acceptance of the results and conclusions, and even then many
in the scientific community will argue over the conclusions because they
themselves wish to prevail with a differing viewpoint or theory that looks
like going "down the tubes" because of this new evidence.
My point in all this is that "we" are aquarists and as such are the consumers
and appliers of the labours of the scientists, if some of us wish to dabble
in the domain of the scientists then "go for it!" As I mentioned before, I
have trouble finding enough time to do my aquarium maintenence without trying
to find time to measure calcium changes in the water in which fry are raised.
I doubt whether the results I obtained would be acceptable to the scientists
even if I went to the trouble. I am not a scientist - I like to think I
practice the "art" and not the "science".
I agree with Andrew that hopefully there should be some ground where we can
help the "true scientists" by providing the skills and materials that they
could benefit from and allow them to do the things that will produce
meaningful and acceptable results. After all it is in our interest to do so.
As a corollary to this science/hobby interface theme how do listmembers
perceive ANGFA's journal " the Fishes of Sahul" - is it a reasonable attempt
to provide such an interface? We on the committee would be grateful for any
comments as the major purpose for starting ANGFA was to provide a vehicle of
information to native fishkeepers through our various publications. We try to
regularly get feedback whenever possible so we can ensure that members'
expectations are met.We would particularly welcome comments from scientists
on avenues, topics and potential authors to help us keep up the scientific
content. Uncle Ron has a very difficult job trying to maintain the "balance"
between articles on collecting, breeding, science etc
In conclusion I will echo Andrew's plea <<Can anyone suggest ways that
hobbyists, their organisations and scientists
can communicate meaningfully?>>
I feel we do contribute , even with our un-corroborated observations and
"unscientific" opinions. If the scientists don't like them then let them
prove them wrong if the subject is worth the trouble or let them offer us a
better "proven and accepted" explanation. Better still let them design an
experiment where we can both contribute our skills and interests to produce
meaningful results After all wee are both supporters of the same club even if
some of us feel the need to support different teams or different levels of
expertise.within that club.
Bruce Hansen.
ANGFA (Q+N)