Re: [RML] Fw: Male or Female Kubutu Rainbowfishes

Adrian R. Tappin (atappin at ecn.net.au)
Sun, 15 Mar 1998 09:21:17 +1000

At 22:44 13/03/98 -0700, Julie wrote:

>I haven't any experience w/ this phenomenon in M. lacustrus, but I have
>observed both G. incisus females and G. ramuensis to do this. The G. ramu
>females were also ones I had spawned, and as a matter of fact, I usually
>only observed flashing behaviour in these females (both spp) while they
>were responding favorably to male courtship and/or in the act of spawning
>itself. I observed this on several occaisions/more than one individual in
>both spp. As I have fry from the ramu females in question, I do not think
>it is a matter of any hormone imbalance/sterility, but rather a normal
>phenomenon. It is VERY subtle, thus hard to miss if you don't know to look
>for it. :) I only saw it the first time by chance.

An interesting subject is hermaphroditism in rainbowfishes. Gerald Allen
noted that Chilatherina fasciata are sometimes hermaphroditic; that is both
male and female reproductive organs are present in the same individual. Nick
Romanowski in the ANGFA Journal 'Fishes of Sahul' reported his observations
of apparent hermaphroditism in Melanotaenia fluviatilis.

I raised this subject some time ago on this list but it never received any
feedback. However, this could well indicate that hermaphrodism may be more
widely deployed in rainbowfishes than previously thought. It may also
explain why Heiko Bleher says that female praecox have yellow fins yet the
original ones (2nd generation wild) I received had red fins. Heiko was very
interested to find out where I had received my fish from and I think perhaps
he thought he had only released male fish. Maybe he did but some of them
became females???

Just a note on ramuensis - I recently raised about 150 fry only to find that
98% of them were females. Anyone else had this happen with ramuensis?

Adrian.
...............................................................
Adrian R. Tappin
"Home of the Rainbowfish"
http://www.ecn.net.au/~atappin/home.htm
...............................................................