Re: Hybrid ethics-was Re: [RML] Melanotaenia marcii

Julie Zeppieri (jazep at www.peter.unmack.net)
Sat, 31 Jan 1998 00:35:16 -0700 (MST)

Hi Rob

I think what has Harro and others of us upset is not the fact that the
fish is a hybrid. While none of us here really cares for hybrids bows, we
all understand your point (below), and it makes sense. :) But I think
what has us steemed (those of us who are) at this guy is the fact that he
is seemingly trying to pass them off as a true species via the name "Mel.
marcii." This is both illegal and immoral -- a fraud. Dead wrong. At
least, that's my opinion of it.

FYI, Marcel et all, these fish are being marketed in the USA under the
name "M. marcii" and we have already had a few dealer inquiries on this
very list as to what this fish is. I, myself, have seen it on a few stock
lists here, and a novice in rainbows could easily think that they were
purchasing a true species of rainbowfish.

I am VERY much against commercial sellers/producers trying to pass off
hybrids as true species, never mind all that trademark/copyright bullsh*t.
I believe others here are too? I would sure like to see that stop.

$.02 (We probably have a fortune in pennies lying around here by
now...) ;) ;)

Julie <><
___________________________________________________

On Fri, 30 Jan 1998, Rob Wager wrote:

> I would like to know why hybrid rainbowfish are not perceived as suitable
> for marketing in the aquarium trade, while truly poxy fish such as orange
> long-finned swordtails are. (Perhaps they are not?)
>
> It seems to me that we might find some answers to the problem of hybrid
> Rainbowfishes by asking people involved in other areas of the aquarium
> hobby. I wonder if the purist livebearer keepers have fits each time they
> see an orange long-finned swordtail?
>
> Colourful livebearers are a very marketable item and raising them can be
> profitable if it is done skilfully. Natural species of livebearers (i.e. the
> wild forms) do not comprise even 0.01 percent of the total livebearer
> market. Yet I imagine that wild forms of livebearers are extremely valuable
> and cherished by livebearer keeping fanatics.
>
> At least in Australia, and probably worldwide, natural species of
> Rainbowfish are only a minor component of total aquarium fish sales. But we
> RMLers love them dearly. What if the "one thank in the lounge room" fish
> buying public create a large demand for a colourful hybridised/selectively
> bred rainbowfish? Is it wrong for someone to profit from supplying such a
> fish? Are they likely to care what we think. And can we, as a very small
> minority, influence the buying habits of others less respectful and
> knowledgable of the variety of rainbows available?
>
> Rob Wager
> Raintree Aquatics Pty Ltd
> Aquatic Environment and Aquaculture Specialists
> 1002 Caboolture River Road
> Rocksberg QLD 4510
> AUSTRALIA
> Phone: 07 5496 7939 Facsimile: 07 5497 0022
> Email: raintree at mail.cth.com.au
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Marcel Beekman <marci at wxs.nl>
> To: rainbowfish at pcug.org.au <rainbowfish at pcug.org.au>
> Date: Friday, 30 January 1998 21:01
> Subject: Re: [RML] Melanotaenia marcii
>
>
> >Hi Harro,
> >
> >
> >Harro.Hieronimus at t-online.de wrote:
> >> He should also be responsible for the M. hammeri. Nevertheless, you
> >> can't have a patent right on a scientific name. This is fraud, what he is
> >> doing! To state it clear again: It is legal to sell crossbreedings under
> >> phantasy names like "Marcis Rainbowfish". But is fraud to sell
> >> crosses under scientific names and their are many ways to sanction
> >> that. Think that: Get a patent right of the name "car". And then
> >> sell rusty cans under this name!
> >
> >Before you take action, a want to correct one thing,
> >if talked to Rinus himself by phone, he has registrated the following
> >names: marcii, hammeri, and greetii. He's not sure if registration =
> >patent right. He hired someone to registrate it for him.
> >
> >> As we know know who does the shit we could try to find ways to
> >> stop that guy. In the next issue of the "Rainbowfish" I'll publish the
> >> facts and maybe one of our Dutch members knows a way to stop that
> >> guy.
> >
> >He is only selling to dutch public, no export to other country's!
> >
> >> Basically that's not interesting. More interesting: Are they fertile?
> >
> >Yes, all three crossbreedings are fertile, he won't tell me the initial
> >species he crossed with.
> >
> >Regards,
> >
> >Marcel Beekman, The Netherlands, Zevenaar.
> >--------------------------------------------
> >(dutch homepage)
> > __ ____
> >Bezoek ook: __/_//__ /
> > / \ /\
> > _/o /_ \/ /
> > \ \ /\ \
> > \_________/ \/
> > \_____\
> >
> > Marcel's Regenboogvissen Homepage
> >
> > http://home.wxs.nl/~marci/
> >
> >...en vul het Gastenboek in.
> >--------------------------------------------
> >
>
>