comments presented in line
In The Dawn of the Third Age "Roy Hunter" <rainbows01 at sprynet.com>
woke me from my contemplation by writing:
>I will jump in at this point.....
>
>You want to know why a lot of Cary's list is not in the program??? I have I
>think all of what he mentioned was not yet in the program. I will tell you
>why, its 150% politics.
Roy I'm really tired of this constant whine of Gary doesn't like me.
When you showed up at the Rainbow 97 convention wanting to sell books
and AGFA memberships did he turn you away or allow you to sell them?
Seems to me I saw a table with ANGFA material and you in the main
room. This was an RSG event, paid for from RSG member's money and yet
ANGFA was represented in the spirit of "what was good for the fish and
hobby, is what was good at the convention".
>I have bred most all of what he mentioned and made
>them available. I have offered them from 8 to 25$ and barely manage to cover
>the costs of getting the fish into the country. I dont raise fish for a
>living I just like to do it for fun and HOPEFULLY the people that get the
>fish from me have fun with them as well. That is where my responsibility
>ends. I have introduced nearly 100 different bows into this country, I cant
>keep and breed them all and I am sure not bringing fish into this country to
>give them away when I spend 4-5,000$ on a trip to OZ I HAVE TRIED on
>many occasions to do a joint effort with the RSG on species maintenance but
>to no avail.
I have seen no effort or proposals on your part to join with RSG in a
species maintenance. Apart from your request that I run a program for
ANGFA also. I do not have time or resources to run two programs and
splitting it into two programs would not be in the fishes interest. I
did tell you that the program was not closed to people outside RSG,
but open to all that wish to partake. You have never taken advantage
of that opportunity or told your membership about it. I've talked to
Gary and he has not received any proposal either.
>See I am the bad guy so the fish I bring in seem to stay in the
>hands of the ANGFA members and the fish that have been in the country for
>quite some time stay in the hands of primarily the RSG members. Just look at
>the list, you have all these things that are common as grass in a field and
>the things that are rare and of good genetic diversity (which would be good
>now to develop a program to protect the genetic diversity as best we can
>with what we have in these fish) slip through the bullshit. So, how serious
>is the quest for a good species maintenance program here in the US?? Not
>very or this would have taken place long ago. It all boils down to a
>political grudge between Gary and myself that I have tried on many occasion
>to put to rest but get absolutely no willingness from Gary to do so. So,
>(sigh) what is in the best interest of the fish or should I say "the species
>maintenance program" will be hindered until some sort of willingness on the
>part of the RSG to work with ANGFA. Its all a bunch of crap, political
>grudges in a hobby are crap, pointing fingers when a species gets lost is
>crap, giving someone a rash of crap if they dont breed the fish they have is
>crap, telling someone you are not going to give them fish if they dont breed
>them is crap,
Who is finger pointing and playing politics now? You complain
constantly about the RSG and Gary. Yet you advertise your fish to RSG
members. I don't see Gary coming here and whining about you on a
regular basis. Give it a rest.
I have never heard anyone say they will not sell fish to some one who
doesn't breed them. But I have heard of people no longer willing to
sell mops because of all the new people that fail to successfully
raise them and they were tired of teaching people. I would also expect
people with the only colony of a species to want to direct their first
stock to somebody that can back them up, another rainbow breeder. Not
doing so jeopardizes the species. Anybody can accidentally loose a
tank full of fish. If its more than one breeders hands it is safe.
When all your eggs are in one basket they can be lost very easily. On
top of this, if I have the only colony I can make the fish available
to only so many people. If I direct my first fry to even three other
breeders, we now have four times the stock that can be made available
to people that wish to just keep the fish.
And yes some of the fish in the program are common as grass.
Boesemani, lacustris, and praecox are just a few of these. But how
many are available that are of good color, finage, body shape? What
sells in the pet stores are very poor comparisons to what these fish
are supposed to look like. The program is aimed to make good quality
stock available to more people, be these common or rare. But many of
the other species are next to impossible to find in the hobby. Do you
really have the only fish worth keeping Roy? I can't force people buy
fish from you Roy. I can't force people to breed these fish or enter
them in the program. I can't buy these fish from you and give them to
people. I can only encourage people to obtain fish, breed them and
enter them in the program. Anything else is outside my control. Do you
have a proposal to get these fish into the program? If so I'd love to
hear it, as I have heard nothing yet from you other than to complain
they are not.
I asked you directly if you had species you planned to keep long term
and could enter into the program yourself. You have failed to enter
any as of this date. I've also told you that bringing in new species
is an important part of the hobby. And if that's what you intend to do
that's great by me. But bringing them in doesn't keep them in the
hobby and that is what this program is about.
>HELLO, WAKE UP the hobby is supposed to be FUN! It is for
>enjoyment! ANYWAY, hobbyists are not the people that are responsible or best
>suited for proper species maintenance. Dr Ivanstoff is on the list and I
>believe (I could be wrong) his department did some gels on the eachamensis
>that were acquired by hobbyists by DPI for the future re-introduction into
>lake Eacham. The report I saw showed a significant drop in genetic diversity
>among those fish compared to the diversity of wild fish of a different
>species. To properly maintain good diversity I believe you need 50 or so
>wild fish and breed them properly. Keeping fish in your living room just for
>fun and gives you an appreciation for the rich tapestry of mother nature and
>that is what we are supposed to have with it.
Nobody every claimed that the species maintenance program was for
reintroducing stock to the wild. In fact it was specifically stated
that the program was to insure good stock for the hobby and not for
any possible reintroduction program. One of the methods proposed by
myself was to actually eliminate genetic diversity and develop stable
hobby strains that looks like wild stock. This has been done
successfully in the live bearer part of the hobby.
You stated to have a program we need to work with ANGFA of NA. Now you
say it is impossible to have a program. You can't have it both ways,
which do you really want? We have 62 species/varieties covered now,
this doesn't sound like an unsuccessful program to me. This program
will go on with or without ANGFA of NA. I've asked you to join, and
I've asked you to inform your membership, you have done neither.
>The best maintenance is through education and protection of the native
>habitat.
There is nothing we can really do in America to further protection of
native habitat in Australia or New Guinea. To think an aquarist
organization can change the policies of multiple governments on the
other side of the world is a little unrealistic. It may sound good but
how many letters has the members of ANGFA of NA written to the
Indonesian, Papuan, or Australian government asking for more
protection for these fish. If they even did would those governments
even care, or are they more concerned about welfare and feeding of
their own constituents? How many public education programs has ANGFA
of NA undertaken in the lands these fish live or do you have any plans
to start any? I think you see my point here.
Cary Hostrawser
My Rainbowfish Home Page
http://pw2.netcom.com/~caryho/home.html
Rainbowfish Study Group Web Page
http://home.stlnet.com/~gwlange/rainbowfish.index.html