Re: [RML] Calcium solution question

Gary Lange (gwlange at stlnet.com)
Tue, 16 Dec 1997 22:54:27 -0600

<snip>
...so I bought a calcium test kit. What I discovered is my
> calcium level is less than 20ppm in my tap water. So though it was
> very hard water, most of the hardness was not cause by calcium.
>
> Generally I have torn down an 10 gallon tank and totally replaced the
> water before adding a mop of eggs. I'll then drop in the mop and one
> HBH balance block. With Melanotaenia, if I have fry with in 24 hours I
> get deformed fry. Fry born after this period do not have the fin
> deformities exhibited by these early born fry. I have yet to actually
> measure the level of calcium added by the balance block in 24 hours,
> but it is obvious that not enough has dissolved to supply the needs of
> the fry.
> I have now began adding calcium chloride to the water, rather than
> waiting for the balance blocks to dissolve. I feel this should give me
> better control over calcium levels without the lag time waiting for
> the blocks to dissolve.
Cary what is the KH of this designed water?
After playing with the reef blocks a few times I reached the same conclusions -
the calcium wasn't available fast enough nor at reliable hardness
concentrations. Besides everything else, compared to calcium chloride, which
can be bought at the hardware store (ice-melt) it is very expensive. With
calcium chloride you just add a certain amount, dissolve it and you're
finished. I would make sure of your hardness before you go adding anything
willy-nilly. For instance Mike Adams mentioned that he used reef blocks in his
set up to add calcium to the water. Perhaps not all of Lexington KY is on the
same water system but the water I measured was 233 ppm (~ 13 drops GH). When I
remeasured with a calcium specific hardness kit (Wardley Professional Test Kit)
it was 100% calcium, not a single bit of magnesium hardness to be found! That
surprised me so much that I repeated both tests. Most public water systems
that I've tested are usually 50:50 magnesium to calcium. Mike if your water is
the same I would suggest that you aren't doing your fry a lot of good with the
blocks. You might be better off adding a bit of baking soda though, the KH of
Lexington is only 2 degrees (36 ppm) hardness. About 1/2 teaspoon/10 gallons
will increase your carbonate hardness about 2 degrees. but.... don't go too
overboard.

Now how the H*** does all of this calcium/magnesium compare to what we see in
nature? Cary, did you see this deformity happen with any Australian rainbows?
I think I have seen it with some trifasciatas. It sounds like quite a few of
the NG fish come from harder water. Some of the other numbers I wouldn't mind
rechecking myself. Some creeks like Harvey's creek are incredibly soft,
essentially 0 degrees GH and KH, pH pretty low too. (springtime, October
measurements). Many of Bruce's measurements also showed these low values. So
how do those fish survive and not all have these fin deformities that we
observe in our aquariums?

My "theory" is that it's a balance between carbonate (KH) and GH (specifically
Calcium). Too much carbonate compared to Calcium and you end up with deformed
fins. My water is 7-8 degrees general hardness GH (about 125-143 ppm). About
1/2 of that is calcium (3.5-4 degrees hardness). My KH, carbonate hardness is
usually around 2 degrees. I normally never have a problem with fin deformities
unless I really abuse the tank by not doing any water changes. I managed to do
that 2 times in about 10 years so it wasn't an everyday occurrence. About a
year or so I started adding enough baking soda to increase the carbonate
hardness by about 2 degrees. (I did this so I would have a more stable pH as
my pH can crash to 5.5 within a few week without a water change). All of a
sudden I started seeing lots of fry with deformed fins. I didn't change
anything in how I was raising fry except for the carbonate value. My carbonate
value was somewhat equal or greater than my calcium hardness value. I managed
to do this to M. papuae and M. trifasciata, canoe creek. I had a few others
too that I trashed right away, happy coal grunter, sad owner. I then started
playing with the calcium blocks and then settled on the more reliable calcium
chloride. I moved my (calcium), GH hardness up about 7 degrees (108 ppm) by
adding 1/2 teaspoons (2.5cc) of calcium chloride per 4 gallons. After that
I've had absolutely no problems with deformed fins on my fry. I think that a
calcium/carbonate balance ratio is the easiest way to explain away this
problem. Otherwise you have to start doing a lot of handwaving in trying to
explain why it doesn't happen to fry in their native waters. Some have
proposed theories about vitamin deficiencies, not the right type of live foods
etc., but I think that's probably reaching too much. This theory would also
suggest why coral/shell grit might not work very well, especially in a fairly
crowded tank. For each bit of calcium you would also be getting an equal
amount of carbonate.

My request to you, especially if you've had problems with deformed fins on your
fry. What is/was the general hardness of your water? If you have a calcium
test kit what percentage of that general hardness is actually calcium? What is
the KH of your water?