And a final note, I think the reason males grow faster than the females is
that they are supposed too! the males are the larger in most cases even in
humans.
Roy Hunter
Co-Chairman
ANGFA of North America
Visit our website at:
http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/royhunter
----------
> From: Cary Hostrawser <caryho at ix.netcom.com>
> To: rainbowfish at pcug.org.au
> Subject: Re: [RML] Sex distribution in fry.
> Date: Monday, December 30, 1996 9:46 PM
>
> On Mon, 30 Dec 1996 13:14:27 -0600, GWLANG at ccmail.monsanto.com wrote:
> >In July I was lucky enough to attend a lecture in San Francisco by Uwe
Romer a
> >German scientist who specializes in dwarf apistos. His experimentations
pretty
> >well proved that temperature plays an incredible part in sex
determinations in
> >dwarf apistos (and some west african dwarfs). I came away from that
lecture
> >remembering 3 numbers 23, 26 29. 23 C (~74F) produced mainly females,
26 C
> >(~79F) equal mixtures, 29 C (~84F) mainly males. The cichlid folks had
for
> >years assumed that the most important factor was pH. He also showed
that this
> >temperature was important from time of birth up to some 33 days. So
during the
> >first 33 days proper temperature was critical if you wanted to obtain a
equal #
> >of males and females. After that timepoint it didn't seem to matter. A
> >question was asked whether this also occurred for other African
cichlids.
> >Although not as carefully proven as his apisto data he stated that it
didn't
> >seem to be a factor for many of the rift lake cichlids.
>
> I've been thinking about this temperature observation with lower temps
> generating more females and warmer temps more males. I have noticed
> that in many species the females seem to lag behind the males growth
> rate. This could be natures way of evening out the odds between faster
> male growth and slower female growth. I've noticed this effect very
> often in aquariums. I'm wondering if you folks, that get the chance to
> collect these fish in the wild, notice that the males are much larger
> than the females in the wild or are the males and females in a school
> pretty much the same size? If the growth rates do differ in the wild
> and the resultant schools of rainbows are closely matched in size,
> this could be an indicator that some factor is correcting for a
> difference in growth rate.
>
> This assumption would also have to be based on a period of the year
> when fry survival is optimized and a majority of the year when very
> few fry survive. Again this is something that hopefully you folks that
> get out and collect could answer. Is there a time of year when no or
> very few fry are found?
>
> I guess where I'm trying to go with this is, nature rarely develops a
> trait that isn't somehow directed towards survival. It could be both
> pH and temp effected fry ratios are in effect for similar reasons and
> mark the same change in seasons. I've really never seen any info on
> the seasonal changes in fish populations and water chemistry. It seems
> most specie are often collected either very rarely and always in the
> same season when its easiest to get to them. If the water conditions
> were tested on the collection date, do we really know what variations
> are going on through the whole season? If there is some data on this,
> it could help to explain why nature may have developed a temperature
> or pH advantage to the sexes.
>
>
> Cary Hostrawser
>
> Minnesota Aquarium Society
> http://www.mn-aquarium.org/
>
> Rainbowfish Study Group of North America
> http://home.earthlink.net/~sbuckel/index.html