Re: [RML] Sex distribution in fry.

Roy Hunter (Rainbows01 at sprynet.com)
Tue, 31 Dec 1996 09:01:21 -0700

When Bruce and I were collecting fish when I was there, the fish were of
all sizes from small ones that you didn't even try to get out of the net,
to larger ones that were probably too large to want to return with. I think
that the fish lay eggs at different times through the year and it would be
difficult to say that this small female would be the same age as this
larger male... Also with the natural temperature changes and differences of
temps at certain depths It would be really hard to say how the ratio was
affected by water temp. There are just too many variables to consider with
out doing it in a tank in a controlled experiment. This test I think would
have no worth as to what determines sex in the wild because the water in
the wild is never constant. If temp is a factor than mother nature has done
a fantastic job making conditions so variable that all sexes will be
represented in close enough to equal ratios and ensuring the survival of
the species. Also with the tank experiment how can you guarantee that the
water chemistry will remain constant in all three tanks? Any variation from
tank to tank can and probably will sway the results of the experiment.

And a final note, I think the reason males grow faster than the females is
that they are supposed too! the males are the larger in most cases even in
humans.

Roy Hunter
Co-Chairman
ANGFA of North America
Visit our website at:
http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/royhunter

----------
> From: Cary Hostrawser <caryho at ix.netcom.com>
> To: rainbowfish at pcug.org.au
> Subject: Re: [RML] Sex distribution in fry.
> Date: Monday, December 30, 1996 9:46 PM
>
> On Mon, 30 Dec 1996 13:14:27 -0600, GWLANG at ccmail.monsanto.com wrote:
> >In July I was lucky enough to attend a lecture in San Francisco by Uwe
Romer a
> >German scientist who specializes in dwarf apistos. His experimentations
pretty
> >well proved that temperature plays an incredible part in sex
determinations in
> >dwarf apistos (and some west african dwarfs). I came away from that
lecture
> >remembering 3 numbers 23, 26 29. 23 C (~74F) produced mainly females,
26 C
> >(~79F) equal mixtures, 29 C (~84F) mainly males. The cichlid folks had
for
> >years assumed that the most important factor was pH. He also showed
that this
> >temperature was important from time of birth up to some 33 days. So
during the
> >first 33 days proper temperature was critical if you wanted to obtain a
equal #
> >of males and females. After that timepoint it didn't seem to matter. A
> >question was asked whether this also occurred for other African
cichlids.
> >Although not as carefully proven as his apisto data he stated that it
didn't
> >seem to be a factor for many of the rift lake cichlids.
>
> I've been thinking about this temperature observation with lower temps
> generating more females and warmer temps more males. I have noticed
> that in many species the females seem to lag behind the males growth
> rate. This could be natures way of evening out the odds between faster
> male growth and slower female growth. I've noticed this effect very
> often in aquariums. I'm wondering if you folks, that get the chance to
> collect these fish in the wild, notice that the males are much larger
> than the females in the wild or are the males and females in a school
> pretty much the same size? If the growth rates do differ in the wild
> and the resultant schools of rainbows are closely matched in size,
> this could be an indicator that some factor is correcting for a
> difference in growth rate.
>
> This assumption would also have to be based on a period of the year
> when fry survival is optimized and a majority of the year when very
> few fry survive. Again this is something that hopefully you folks that
> get out and collect could answer. Is there a time of year when no or
> very few fry are found?
>
> I guess where I'm trying to go with this is, nature rarely develops a
> trait that isn't somehow directed towards survival. It could be both
> pH and temp effected fry ratios are in effect for similar reasons and
> mark the same change in seasons. I've really never seen any info on
> the seasonal changes in fish populations and water chemistry. It seems
> most specie are often collected either very rarely and always in the
> same season when its easiest to get to them. If the water conditions
> were tested on the collection date, do we really know what variations
> are going on through the whole season? If there is some data on this,
> it could help to explain why nature may have developed a temperature
> or pH advantage to the sexes.
>
>
> Cary Hostrawser
>
> Minnesota Aquarium Society
> http://www.mn-aquarium.org/
>
> Rainbowfish Study Group of North America
> http://home.earthlink.net/~sbuckel/index.html