Re: Males

Ted Northrop (ted at astro.ocis.temple.edu)
Sat, 10 Aug 1996 16:35:44 -0400 (EDT)

On 9 Aug 1996, roy hunter wrote:

> Chris, tell that *&^^&^ that is feeding the females that when Hunter gets back
> with his fish he will breed a load of them and place a add in FAMA and everyone
> in his area will get a discount. I'll just price him right out of the market and
> hopefully put an end to that bull$$%$! People who do that should be SHOT!

Being in the field of economics I find it interesting how people apply
economics to this situation we have been discussing.
Roy above has aptly stated the result of a free market system, I love it
:)
First let me just say that the one individual who said the industry
should be concerned about regulations to enforce the conservation of
certain species as a means of protecting future economic value for the
industry is way off. The problem here is first ( if I am not mistaken)
many of the fish are breed in ponds/hatcheries etc.. so the state of
the stock in the wild is of no concern or very little concern to the
wholesaler/breeder. Also the problem is for fish collected in the
wild streams/waters are used by all collectors so even if all collectors
cared as individuals about the stock of wild fish and were careful in
collecting so as to protect future value they only measure their impact
or are aware of their impact. SO the result is the each individual is
careful but only has acted in a way that accounts for his marginal
damage, when in reality the culmination of the damage is much higher.
Lets assume everyone knows their damage and everyone elses damage we
have changed the rules now, as those who want to make money on the
collection site will collect hard and faster than everyone else so as
to reap the benefits before the stream is destroyed, result
accelerated destruction.
So almost anyway you look at it unintentioned or intentioned the
industry causes destruction if left to their own devices.

O.K. one more mental excercise in economics, If wholesalers/importers only
sell males they have actually driven up the price for females by causing
a shortage, so why don't we see a market for males and females with
different prices??? Dunno know I can only guess that not enough people
are really interested in breeding. Yet their are some and these people
are know willing to pay a premium for females which means guys like
Roy can know enter the market with his females and make some money.
The problem is if the importers faced more competition they would have
to sell females, because their is not enough competition they are able
to control supply to the market in hopes of extending the time frame
that they excercise that control.

That's it sorry if I bored you I just thought it was interesting
Ted